Tuesday, November 24, 2009
My response to Joseph Rose of the Oregonian
Mr. Joseph Rose of the Oregonian, found my blog and is not happy about some of what I wrote yesterday.
Mr. Rose,
Let's start with the most pressing "hot button" topic of our day in public transit:
I do not condone MAX or bus operators texting or using cell phones while operating their vehicles. The rule against this has been on the books at TriMet for a long, long time. Those who break this rule should be disciplined as harshly as TriMet deems fit. The recent announcement that TriMet now has a rule about this, is misleading; it is not a new rule, it is simply an old rule that will now be strictly enforced.
I become very concerned when I see or hear about any TriMet operator giving less than full attention to his or her job. My job requires me to give 100 % every day, something that is not always easy. However, along with most other TriMet bus and rail operators, I try my best. I remind myself daily that people's lives are in my hands, sometimes quiet literally when they carelessly run in front of my moving train.
I understand that you have tried to drive a TriMet bus; however, trying to drive a 40 foot bus does not show you how to walk in my shoes as a MAX operator. Operating a MAX train is so different than driving a bus that there is no way you can imagine what it is like WITHOUT having tried MAX.
I am sure that you would get a new perspective on my job if you could see it from the inside of my cab while listening to the radio and following in detail all we have to do and pay attention to. (Unfortunately, I could not let you ride in my cab without special permission.) Downtown Portland looks a lot different from my cab than it does from the seat of a bus driver.
Please do not misunderstand me: driving a bus is very challenging and a huge responsibility - I did it for seven years and it is as stressful a job as you could ever wish to have. Perhaps driving a bus partially prepares you for operating MAX - not sure about that, but it could. Come to think of it, I am pretty sure there is a transit agency here in the United States that found that light rail operators without a bus background were safer than those with. I would have to dig a little to find that piece of information again.
Just like in every other job, there are good TriMet operators and bad ones. Some should not be driving a bus, and some should not be operating MAX. I do not make the decisions about who should or should not work at TriMet - my job is to operate my trains as safely as I can every time I get into that cab. If I am not "fit for duty" it is my responsibility to take myself off the train - which I have in the past when I have been too sick to safely operate my train.
When accidents and incidents happen at MAX it becomes big news; the recent story about the three year old boy being left at a platform is a horrible example of something that should not have happened.
But please do NOT judge all of us because of the bad apples in our ranks. Most MAX operators are responsible and safe operators. Most are patient and helpful. Lately, I have seen a tendency to lump us all into this "awful operator" category, whether that be bus or train operators. Most of us do well with the public, most of us are safe, most of us will help you when you need help. That is part of our job, whether we operate a bus or a MAX train.
Mr. Rose, I am not here to argue with you. You may think whatever you want about TriMet and it's employees - and me. We live in a free country, and we still have freedom of speech. Just don't think you know all there is to know about TriMet just because you blog about us.
And, at the same time, I will remind myself that I do not know all there is to know about TriMet, either. I am "only" a rail operator, and can only blog about things the way I see them...
Mr. Rose, most MAX operators have only one goal in mind: to get you safely to your destination, without any incidents. That goal enccompasses everything about this job, a job that is challenging, enjoyable and rewarding.
I hope some day I will meet you; it would be an interesting meeting - in a good way.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Eva
Mr. Rose,
Let's start with the most pressing "hot button" topic of our day in public transit:
I do not condone MAX or bus operators texting or using cell phones while operating their vehicles. The rule against this has been on the books at TriMet for a long, long time. Those who break this rule should be disciplined as harshly as TriMet deems fit. The recent announcement that TriMet now has a rule about this, is misleading; it is not a new rule, it is simply an old rule that will now be strictly enforced.
I become very concerned when I see or hear about any TriMet operator giving less than full attention to his or her job. My job requires me to give 100 % every day, something that is not always easy. However, along with most other TriMet bus and rail operators, I try my best. I remind myself daily that people's lives are in my hands, sometimes quiet literally when they carelessly run in front of my moving train.
I understand that you have tried to drive a TriMet bus; however, trying to drive a 40 foot bus does not show you how to walk in my shoes as a MAX operator. Operating a MAX train is so different than driving a bus that there is no way you can imagine what it is like WITHOUT having tried MAX.
I am sure that you would get a new perspective on my job if you could see it from the inside of my cab while listening to the radio and following in detail all we have to do and pay attention to. (Unfortunately, I could not let you ride in my cab without special permission.) Downtown Portland looks a lot different from my cab than it does from the seat of a bus driver.
Please do not misunderstand me: driving a bus is very challenging and a huge responsibility - I did it for seven years and it is as stressful a job as you could ever wish to have. Perhaps driving a bus partially prepares you for operating MAX - not sure about that, but it could. Come to think of it, I am pretty sure there is a transit agency here in the United States that found that light rail operators without a bus background were safer than those with. I would have to dig a little to find that piece of information again.
Just like in every other job, there are good TriMet operators and bad ones. Some should not be driving a bus, and some should not be operating MAX. I do not make the decisions about who should or should not work at TriMet - my job is to operate my trains as safely as I can every time I get into that cab. If I am not "fit for duty" it is my responsibility to take myself off the train - which I have in the past when I have been too sick to safely operate my train.
When accidents and incidents happen at MAX it becomes big news; the recent story about the three year old boy being left at a platform is a horrible example of something that should not have happened.
But please do NOT judge all of us because of the bad apples in our ranks. Most MAX operators are responsible and safe operators. Most are patient and helpful. Lately, I have seen a tendency to lump us all into this "awful operator" category, whether that be bus or train operators. Most of us do well with the public, most of us are safe, most of us will help you when you need help. That is part of our job, whether we operate a bus or a MAX train.
Mr. Rose, I am not here to argue with you. You may think whatever you want about TriMet and it's employees - and me. We live in a free country, and we still have freedom of speech. Just don't think you know all there is to know about TriMet just because you blog about us.
And, at the same time, I will remind myself that I do not know all there is to know about TriMet, either. I am "only" a rail operator, and can only blog about things the way I see them...
Mr. Rose, most MAX operators have only one goal in mind: to get you safely to your destination, without any incidents. That goal enccompasses everything about this job, a job that is challenging, enjoyable and rewarding.
I hope some day I will meet you; it would be an interesting meeting - in a good way.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Eva
Labels:
Joseph Rose,
light rail,
Max,
TriMet
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

7 comments:
Everyone has an opinion of everything, just like the ones that think transit should just go away.
Took me over a month to get "Special Permission" to make the Green Line Timelapse, as much as I would love to do the other alignments, I don't have my hopes up. My Idiots Video caught 2 people and 1 car on the same run!
Keep up the good work, and the positive blog, its refreshing!
Punkrawker, of course you are right; we all have a right to our opinions. It just bothers me when somebody tells me that they have "walked in my shoes" as a rail operator - when they have only tried to drive a bus!
Just amazes me how anybody could think the two vehicles are anything like each other...
Oh, well... :-)
The special permissions for a ride a long are rightfully difficult to get. Hopefully you will get permission for more of the alignment, though. Your footage is great!
I was in Portland over the weekend (stopover on an Amtrak trip) and took some video (Goose Hollow to Beaverton, both directions...did in downtown too but my fat thumb accidentally deleted it, oops!) from behind the Type 4 cab window. Will I get in trouble for posting on YouTube? I'd love to share it, but I don't want to get TriMet mad at me, or make it so that even fewer of those windows are open...
Everyone is a critic.
It has been an interesting and very eventful week in our small city. This week we should all take time to be thankful: everyone needs to remember that we actually have a decent transit system to get us from A to B, road or rail; police and inspectors work hard to keep us safe; and even though unfortunate events happen from time to time I hope that everyone can learn from them and then do better.
Thanks for sharing your life as an operator with us EMS, its a very unique and interesting story!
Nathan, anything you take a video of as a passenger is fair game; there are a lot of videos on YouTube taken by passengers.
Please send me a link in a comment so I can see it. I may put a link to your video on my blog, if you don't mind...
Eva
Eva,
Thanks for responding to my blog post and stories.
Of course I wasn't saying that spending an hour behind the wheel of a bus is anywhere near walking and driving in your shoes. My point was that I have taken every opportunity offered by TriMet and your fellow operators -- even the ones who threaten to box my lights out -- to gain as much perspective as possible. In other words, I'm not just writing about these issues, holed up in my cubicle. I'm sorry if that was misinterpreted.
I'm a frequent transit rider, for work and pleasure, and you're right: Most operators I have encountered are top notch. I've actually written more "positive" stories about operators. But it's the watchdog stuff with the tough questions and less than flattering facts that you remember. Either way, I feel that I have always been fair.
I hope to meet you soon, too.
All the best and safe travels.
Joseph Rose
Ah - I need to pay attention to my spell check...
To you who reminded me, THANK YOU!
HAPPY THANKSGIVING... :-)
Post a Comment